woman pouring kettle and fire bone broth

Kettle & Fire Vs. Dr. Kellyann — Which Bone Broth Do We Recommend?

If you’re into health and wellness at all, you’ve probably heard of the new, emerging trend: bone broth.

Except, it's actually not new at all. Bone broth is one of the oldest health and wellness tricks in the book — dating back to prehistoric times! It helps with digestion and gut health, joint mobility and recovery, immune function, anti-inflammatory responses, and even weight management.

Instead of having to simmer bones yourself for 8 to 12 hours in order to have bone broth, nowadays there are companies who slow-simmer the broth for you, making bone broth easily accessible, and even more effective. All you have to do is consume it and reap the benefits!

Our editors wanted to know which company is making the best bone broth, so we compared two of the leading contenders in the space: Kettle & Fire and Dr. Kellyann.

Both brands offer a vast range of products, so for the sake of this comparison, we looked only at their liquid bone broth. Here’s what we found:

Key Similarities

  • Both companies offer liquid bone broth in chicken or beef flavors
  • Both offer grass-fed, organic, non-GMO bone broth
  • Both offer keto and paleo options

Key Differences

  • Kettle & Fire has a bigger variety of flavors, like Mushroom Chicken Bone Broth and Turmeric Ginger Bone Broth
  • Kettle & Fire’s flavors are tastier than Dr. Kellyann’s
  • Dr. Kellyann’s bone broth comes frozen, Kettle & Fire comes as liquid
  • Kettle & Fire’s liquid bone broth starts at $3.20 per serving and Dr. Kellyann’s liquid bone broth starts at about $6 per serving

Kettle & Fire

The first thing we liked about Kettle & Fire is how easy their site is to navigate. Each product has tons of information including reviews so you can not only do your research, but also hear what other people are saying about their products.

When we saw the thousands of 5-star reviews Kettle & Fire’s bone broth has, we had high expectations. We ordered 4 flavors of their liquid bone broth — Beef, Chicken, Mushroom Chicken, and Turmeric Ginger.

It was our first time trying bone broth so we didn’t know what to expect, but we were pleasantly surprised when we actually enjoyed every flavor. The broth tasted unbelievably rich and delicious. Our favorite was the Mushroom Chicken bone broth, but honestly there wasn’t one we didn’t like. We even cooked with the broth as it adds the perfect richness to any dish.

We love that Kettle & Fire has a subscription option too, so you never have to worry about running out or staying on top of your health — your next batch arrives on your doorstep like clockwork without you lifting a finger! Not to mention that subscribers get their bone broth for just $3.20 per serving!

Dr. Kellyann

We noticed that Dr. Kellyann’s Beef Bone Broth only had 8 reviews compared to Kettle & Fire’s 8000 5-star reviews. We didn’t see any subscription options on the product page either.

In terms of liquid bone broth, Dr. Kellyann only has two flavors — Chicken or Beef. We ordered both.

We’ll be completely honest and say the taste of the beef and chicken broths were pretty similar to Kettle & Fire’s, if not a bit more watered down — perhaps because it arrives frozen. Still, Kettle & Fire’s Mushroom Chicken and Turmeric Ginger were a lot tastier.

The main difference here is the cost. Dr. Kellyann’s broth starts at about $6 per serving, which is significantly higher than Kettle & Fire (almost double), even though it didn’t measure up flavor-wise.

Final Thoughts

We’re choosing Kettle & Fire, hands down. They offer a variety of flavors, their bone broth tastes amazing, and most of all, it's more affordable — starting at just $3.20 per serving.

Not to mention, Kettle & Fire’s convenient subscription option allows you to not only save, but it means you don’t have to log in and re-order every time you’re running out.

Kettle & Fire uses bones from chicken and cattle that are humanely-raised, 100% grass-fed cattle, free-range organic chicken, and don’t include any antibiotics, hormones, extra sodium, artificial flavors, additives, or preservatives.

Kettle & Fire’s bone broth is USDA Certified Organic or grass-fed and Whole30 approved. Plus its Certified Glyphosate Residue Free so it’s definitely the best of the best. And it's great for anyone on Keto, Paleo or who just wants to improve their overall health and wellness!

After 6 weeks of drinking Kettle & Fire bone broth, we definitely noticed a difference. Our skin looked healthier, and our hair and nails were stronger, too! Even our gut health has improved significantly and we’re sleeping better. This stuff WORKS!

Check out Kettle & Fire’s Bone Broth now. You can thank us later!

The team at Kettle & Fire is extending a special offer to our readers! Follow this link to get up to 30% OFF your first order + FREE Shipping!

Latest Articles from Topdust